
Barry Zito is an enigma. He knows this. You know this.
He’s coming so far from the bottom, he can’t even see the top. This season has been a delightful surprise for one of the San Francisco Giants’ most poignant punchlines because of his demurred star quality in black and orange. With his last three starts worthy of making any pitching coach’s mouth water, the enigma has extended a leaf of hope to what he may offer this season for the Giants and for this ever-critical fan.
Zito’s got quirks. If you’re following him on Twitter, you know he’s a hoot. And apparently he’s got his swagger back. He’s allowed three runs in his last three starts, given up 13 hits, walked four and struck out 11. All of these games have been no-decisions for the Giants’ No. 4 pitcher, making his 0-2 record not representative of his body of work which has bordered on beautiful.
(Somebody, start knocking on wood.)
This coming from the man who showed up in spring training three years ago with a changed delivery.
“Uh, coach, I think I’m going to try something new.”
“But you’re a Cy Young winner,” says pitching coach Dave Righetti. “Why would you want to change anything?”
“Yeah, I’m getting bored with success. I’m going to try losing for a while and see how it feels.”
I swore I wouldn’t even mention Zito at the beginning of this season, or at least overindulge in my critiques of him because there is still a sensitivity to the $18 million failure characterized as “last season.” He’s a sore spot in an otherwise bright rotation that has been consistently — up until two weeks ago — a source of my absolute hatred. So much so, that criticism of this wayward pitcher has depleted all flavor in the tongue lashings he has respectfully deserved.
Can we say, no more?
His two-hit outing this weekend against the Rockies brought me absolute joy. It was reminiscent of a different Zito. A Zito that was almost feared on the mound at Network Coliseum.
As a Giants fan, I haven’t seen much of that Zito. That Zito was thought to be long dead. Or at least buried deep within the mind of this zombie that Twitter’s quotes from Helene Lerner Robbins like, “The evils of the world that confront me are a reflection of my own internal state, and no one can protect me from my own mind.”
Coming deep from within that abyss of his mind has been the pitcher the Giants paid $126 million. He’s summoned the talent that we all expected of him and were excited for in these last three starts. The results haven’t been anything less than inspiring.
But I have to tread carefully here. I don’t want Zito to get comfortable. He still hasn’t recorded a win. We’re just getting a glimpse of Zito recapturing his form. The end product is still undetermined. For God’s sake, he’s Barry Zito. He’s disappointed us before. What says he won’t do so again?
Zito is getting my hopes up. And for the first time in two years, I am earnestly waiting for him to turn it around — on his time. He’s got a long way to go before memories of seasons past are forgotten. But his last three outings are a start to some healthy amnesia.
I’ll take the amnesia any day.
Editor’s note: This column originally appeared in The Union.